Local participation in REDD+ forest conservation projects in Brazil

Comparing substantively meaningful effect sizes (shaded regions) to estimated effect

While there is a growing concensus that participation in sustainable development efforts is normatively important, its impacts on the environmental performance of these projects is less clear. Does increasing participation improve environmental outcomes, threaten them, or neither? This study examines the effect of local participation on forest conservation projects in Brazil that are associated with a high-profile international initiative called REDD+. Theoretically-grounded measures of participation are constructed through a review of public project documentation. An extension of the synthetic control approach is then used to assess the conservation value-added of high levels of participation within this sample. Counter to some strong arguments in both directions in the literature, high participation appears to at most have a minor negative effect on the ability of these REDD+ efforts to slow forest loss. This study concludes by weighing the implications of that finding for our understanding of participatory development initiatives.

Bill Schultz
Bill Schultz
Asst. Instructional Professor

My substantive research interests include international development, conservation efforts, and resource politics. Methodologically, I’m interested in geospatial data, causal inference, and game theory.